Connect with us

Articles

The Paradox of Progress – Abdul Mahmud

Published

on

By Abdul Mahmud

A country can build magnificent highways, commission hospitals, expand its airports and announce impressive economic growth figures, yet leave its citizens less free than they were before. Its government may celebrate new investments, point to rising GDP and parade infrastructure projects as evidence of national transformation; but beneath the spectacle of development, something fundamental may be disappearing: the freedom of citizens to question power, challenge public policy, organise against injustice and participate meaningfully in the government of their country. What, then, is the meaning of progress when the material conditions of life improve but the political conditions of freedom deteriorate?

The above question posed recently by Nathalie Delapalme is particularly instructive. Delapalme is the Chief Executive Officer of the Mo Ibrahim Foundation, which she joined in 2010. Before that appointment, she held senior positions in the French public service, including serving as Inspecteur Général des Finances at the French Ministry of Economy and Finance between 2007 and 2010. She also advised successive French foreign affairs ministers on Africa and development. Her observation, therefore, comes from someone whose professional experience straddles public administration, international development and African governance. The question appeared in the context of the Foundation’s assessment of governance across the continent.

The underlying argument deserves serious consideration because Africa’s development debate has for too long been dominated by the economics of physical infrastructure. Governments measure achievement in kilometres of roads constructed, megawatts of electricity generated, hospitals commissioned and billions of dollars attracted in foreign investment. These are important indicators. No serious development argument can dismiss the importance of roads, hospitals, electricity and employment. The difficulty begins when governments treat these achievements as sufficient evidence of good governance. Development is not simply the capacity of a state to construct things; it is also the capacity of that state to guarantee the conditions under which its citizens can live with dignity and exercise their freedoms. A hospital may provide healthcare, but a government that denies citizens the freedom to criticise its failures undermines their ability to demand better healthcare. A road may connect two communities, but a political environment that prevents those communities from organising to demand public accountability diminishes the value of that connection.

The distinction is between development as a collection of government projects and development as an expansion of human freedom. Amartya Sen, the Nobel laureate economist, made this argument in Development as Freedom. His central proposition was that development must be understood as the expansion of people’s substantive freedoms and capabilities. Economic prosperity is important, but its importance cannot be separated from the freedoms that enable individuals to determine the direction of their lives. This is precisely where the African development conversation needs a fundamental reorientation. The 2026 Ibrahim Index of African Governance, which assesses governance performance across 54 African countries over the decade 2016–2025, provides compelling evidence. Africa’s average overall governance score improved by just 0.8 points over the period. Economic opportunity and human development recorded improvements, but security, rule of law, participation, rights and inclusion declined. Corruption also deteriorated in 28 countries, accounting for almost 60 per cent of the continent’s population. These findings expose the limitations of celebrating economic and infrastructural achievements without examining the institutional environment in which they occur.

Nigeria provides an important illustration. The 2026 Freedom House assessment gives the country 44 out of 100 and classifies it as Partly Free. Its assessment identifies continuing problems with electoral irregularities, restrictions on press freedom, harassment of journalists and abuses by security agencies. The country’s democratic institutions formally guarantee political participation and fundamental rights, but the distance between constitutional guarantees and citizens’ lived experiences remains considerable. The implications extend beyond the familiar problem of human rights violations. A shrinking political space weakens the mechanisms through which societies correct their mistakes. Citizens who cannot freely criticise government policies lose an important means of influencing public decisions. Journalists who face intimidation cannot investigate public expenditure with the independence required of their profession. Civil society organisations that encounter administrative and political obstacles cannot perform their watchdog functions effectively. Opposition parties denied meaningful access to public political spaces cannot compete on equal terms.

The result is a governance environment in which governments increasingly become the judges of their own performance. Public expenditure escapes sufficient scrutiny, institutional failures persist and the distance between political authority and popular accountability widens. Infrastructure may be visible, but the institutional failures accompanying it are often less apparent.

There is also a constitutional dimension to this argument. The legitimacy of democratic government does not derive simply from its capacity to deliver public goods; it derives from the consent of the governed, exercised through constitutional institutions and protected political freedoms. In Nigeria, section 14(2)(a) of the 1999 Constitution declares that sovereignty belongs to the people, from whom government derives its powers and authority. Section 14(2)(b) makes the security and welfare of the people the primary purpose of government. These provisions cannot be meaningfully separated from the fundamental rights guaranteed under Chapter IV. The implication is that development cannot become an excuse for restricting the very freedoms through which citizens hold government accountable. Nor should economic performance be deployed as a substitute for constitutional legitimacy. Africa must also confront the temptation to measure its development against the preferences of investors, international financial institutions and external development partners while overlooking the ordinary citizen. Foreign investment, fiscal stability and economic growth matter. But the ultimate beneficiaries of development should be the people whose labour, resources and taxes sustain the state. Their freedoms cannot be treated as expendable costs of economic modernisation.

The road to development must lead somewhere beyond the next infrastructure commissioning ceremony. It must lead to a society in which citizens can speak without fear, institutions can exercise their constitutional independence and governments can be held accountable for their decisions. Delapalme’s question is therefore not an argument against building roads or hospitals. It is an invitation to reconsider what we mean by progress. A nation should not have to choose between material development and political freedom. Both are indispensable to a meaningful conception of human advancement. So, a road that connects cities but leaves citizens disconnected from the exercise of political power is an incomplete achievement, just as the hospital that saves lives in a country where citizens cannot freely demand accountability from those governing them tells only half the story of development.

The true measure of progress is not simply what a government builds for its people, but also what it permits its people to become.

For publication of your news content, articles, videos or any other news worthy materials, please send to newsleverage1@gmail.com. For more enquiry, please call +234-901-067-1763 or whatsapp +234-901-067-1763. To place an advert, please call 09010671763

Advertisement

Trending

Copyright © All rights reserved. | Developed By by Media King INC +2348062867011.